Best Pizza in NYC

There truly is nothing like a NYC slice, and when it comes to the best pizza in NYC, I know a thing or two. Considering no other pizza can compare, you can pretty much go anywhere and it will be better than any pizza you have eaten around the world, but there are some specific qualifications that make each place on this list unique and worthy of a visit. I don’t mean to brag, but these NYC pizza spots are so delicious that any other rec out there is probably lying, sorry! Let’s explore the best pizza in NYC, so you can experience pizza like a true local. 

What Makes a Good Pizza?

What differentiates NYC pizza from around the world and across the nation is that the water we have here is so fresh. The water is truly what differentiates pizza in a standout way. On the contrary, if you have ever visited Florida and tried their pizza, you may just barf. 

Some people prefer a more saucy pizza, less cheese, more cheese, more dough, less dough. But all in all, it’s how it all combines together that makes it so unique. Depending on what your criteria for a perfect pizza are, your list may look a bit different. All in all, these spots are sure to be a showstopper, and you may just want to go back.

The Best Pizza in NYC

1. Table 87: I can’t create a “Best Pizza in NYC” post without putting this spot as #1. Table 87 has the kind of pizza that surpasses the others. The crust is thin with cheese that melts off the mouth, generous sauce, and the biggest pieces of basil I have ever seen. The thing about this place is that you can order their pizza frozen and have it later, and it tastes just as good. Dining at this restaurant is a go-to for my family. The arugula salad is scrumptious, and for dessert, they have Nutella pizza that will blow you away. There are 3 locations in Brooklyn, so there is no excuse not to visit. 
2. Joe’s: This place is famous for not just any reason. The pizza is too good. It’s a classic NYC slice that has lines out the door in any location. For someone visiting for the first time, you really do have to try Joe’s and experience it. Just be prepared to wait a bit, and you’ll be okay. 
3. Whit’s: This is another spot that I crave pretty often. Number 3 on the best pizza in NYC is an unassuming restaurant in Rockaway Beach, Queens. The owner is a character in itself, but in the best way- it adds to the charm and how dedicated he is to the community, creating spaces like Whits for people to enjoy and eat delicious food. The pizzas here are top-tier. The place is currently closed, but I have a feeling he is going to make a comeback, so just you wait!
4. L&B: Another classic Brooklyn spot is L&B Spumoni Gardens. You can’t go here and not get the Sicilian square slice. It’s mouthwatering, scrumptious, and you’ll probably eat this in one bite. A lot of the time, we’ll order a whole Sicilian pie with a group of people, and any leftovers just pop into the fridge for later. 
5. Dani’s: If you like sweet sauce, this spot is for you. Dani’s in Kew Gardens is a local favorite, with lines out the door and anxious people awaiting a delicious bite. There’s a good reason why Dani’s is in business and operating. 
6. Lenny & Johns: If you prefer a more doughy piece, Lenny & John’s is your go-to. Growing up, we’d always order pizza here, and with good reason. On your way to a picnic in Marine Park or Riis Beach, order to go and then dig in. 
7. Champion: This is the spot you’ll most likely go to after a night out. Pizza is delicious and packs a powerful punch. 

There You Have It

The Best Pizza in NYC just became easier to navigate with this list of local favorites. NYC pizza truly hits different, and with these spots, you are guaranteed to get the true local experience.

Veronica

Hi everyone! My name is Veronica, but you can also call me Vee! I grew up in the iconic city of Brooklyn, NY, the cultural hub of the world, and hence learned about so many different cultures. It was those experiences that inspired me to travel and from then on, I had learned the power of travel. In return, I want to give others that same experience, to help inspire others to unleash their inner travel enthusiast no matter the trip.

See Full Bio